Switching Back To Windows – The End Of An Era

For just over a year I’ve used a variety of Apple devices — from the Xserve and Mac Pro to the iPhone and MacBook Pro — and even a Mac Mini — as my primary work systems in a Windows-oriented IT shop.

I made the switch because Apple PCs and iPhones — and now iPads — are coming into the enterprise. I wanted to travel with IT managers who were acquiring skills and products to effectively manage these alluring, adept client devices that captivate the hearts and minds of high-value, and therefore important to please, employees.

The endorphin rush when things “just work”

Free Prize Draw: Win one of the first iPads in Britain

With the help of desktop virtualisation tools that enabled me to easily access my email via the Microsoft Outlook client running on a Windows 7 virtual machine, my experience showed that a longtime Windows user can adjust to life on a Mac. I didn’t become a fanboy, but I experienced the endorphin rush that most Mac users speak of when things “just worked.”

I’m turning the “Apple in the Enterprise” beat over to the capable P. J. Connolly, who recently joined our staff. Connolly is a seasoned Mac user and brings a background of Apple coverage to eWEEK. He will continue our Mac-oriented product reviews and IT-oriented Apple analysis.

As I reflect on the important lessons I learned during my travel through the land of Apple, I still wonder about the usefulness of the fat client to the bulk of business IT. And it is this questioning that holds me back from fandom either for Apple’s “Snow Leopard” operating system or Microsoft’s Windows 7, the operating system I started using full-time today. But before I go too far into future musings on the changes in store for end-user computing, here are the lessons I learned from my year on Macs.

First, it was great to not worry about antivirus protection. My Mac got security updates — many of which required a reboot — almost as often as the Windows systems running in eWEEK Labs, but I never had to wait for a virus signature update or a pesky system scan. It was strangely odd to bank, check my credit card and shop online without really worrying about the security or safety of the personal computer (I was reminded many times by Apple users that Macs are PCs) I was using to visit those sites.

Second, it was awesome to have stuff “just work.” This was true for my Mac desktop and server systems as well as my iPhone. As much as I like to tinker with a PC or phone, from an IT operations point of view, having applications install and work correctly was a luxurious experience.

Finally, my MacWorld experience showed that enterprise management tools for Apple products are bobbing to the surface. IT managers in regulated industries should acquire tools that bring the Mac into the management fold for compliance reasons. Configuration management tools are also available to help ensure that required software and patches are available so end users can concentrate on work, not system management.

Although Apple and Microsoft marketing encourages a childish snarling contest between the platforms, my experience showed me that IT managers must take a no-nonsense approach to system management. Once a corporate decision is made to support multiple desktop operating systems, there’s no way a fan-based attitude toward one OS is going to make it easy or cheap to manage a second or third platform.

Despite the fun I had learning my Mac systems, what is becoming clear is that as I do more work on hosted applications my end-user priorities are shifting. In my changing enterprise world I care more about display size, network response time and remote printer support than whether my local PC is running Snow Leopard, Windows 7 or Linux.

Cameron Sturdevant eWEEK USA 2012. Ziff Davis Enterprise Inc. All Rights Reserved.

View Comments

  • A fairly blase review of his experiences. No bark and no bite. I think the review was real short and didn't discuss much in terms substance.

    It almost seemed there wasn't much negative, but the headline conveyed a much different story. But what can one expect from headlines?

  • Since when does an "era" last "just over a year?" According to my dictionary, an era is "a long and distinct period of history with a particular feature or characteristic." Your headline writer is a moron.

  • @Mew

    This was not meant to be "a review"; this article strikes me as one's ruminations about using a Mac in the enterprise for a year. In this context he spoke of some of the more subtle yet pleasant user experiences that Windows users do not typically enjoy; things that go beyond specs and how many ports some hardware has.

    All in all, the article is what it is -- and it was not meant to be a review.

  • As someone struggling to understand Windows 7 and Ubuntu on Linux, who has worked for an "era," i.e. twenty odd years on Macs, I had hoped for more specifics. Things do just "work" on the Mac, and trying to find information from Microsoft and their glossy guides is very difficult. The new Macbook pros once again offer mediocre interfaces with the exception of the 17 inch which carries the e-sata interface. The price and port restrictions of the Air forced me to buy a Lenovo U-150 for hauling on buses, etc. I miss the Mac community in trying to use new machine and begin to dream of a middle ground.

  • Interesting comment that "...it was awesome that things just work." This has been said about the Mac for years that this is a grossly exaggerated claim made by Mac fanboys. Yet, here you have an IT professional that documents this experience with his personal experience. Can you imagine a platform that you don't have to babysit just to keep it working? Can you imagine the potential cost savings to IT budgets world wide if they adopted such a platform. Heck, forget the savings and reinvest in making more things "just work?"

    I manage a small shop with 20+ Macs as a part time IT guy. It is very refreshing to focus on my work and face fewer fire drills. Now if I could just eliminate my frustrations with those Olympus digital voice recorder failures.

  • As an engineer, the Mac lets me use whatever OS I need to get the work done.

    Right now that means CAD-Excel analysis stuff on Windows & the rest on OSX SL.

    What I do NOT want is 2 laptops.

Share
Published by
Cameron Sturdevant eWEEK USA 2012. Ziff Davis Enterprise Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Tags: desktop

Recent Posts

Craig Wright Sentenced For Contempt Of Court

Suspended prison sentence for Craig Wright for “flagrant breach” of court order, after his false…

3 days ago

El Salvador To Sell Or Discontinue Bitcoin Wallet, After IMF Deal

Cash-strapped south American country agrees to sell or discontinue its national Bitcoin wallet after signing…

3 days ago

UK’s ICO Labels Google ‘Irresponsible’ For Tracking Change

Google's change will allow advertisers to track customers' digital “fingerprints”, but UK data protection watchdog…

3 days ago

EU Publishes iOS Interoperability Plans

European Commission publishes preliminary instructions to Apple on how to open up iOS to rivals,…

3 days ago

Momeni Convicted In Bob Lee Murder

San Francisco jury finds Nima Momeni guilty of second-degree murder of Cash App founder Bob…

3 days ago