Nexus One Maker Tells Apple ‘We Did Touchscreens First’

HTC, the maker of Google’s Nexus One phone, has issued a release saying it will defend itself against a law suit which alleges the phone breaks Apple patents.

The HTC release points to the company’s experience in phones, including touchscreen devices which pre-date the Apple iPhone, and promises to defend itself in court should the need arise, following the announcement that Apple is suing HTC for infringement of patents used in the iPhone.

HTC claims touchscreen skills

“HTC disagrees with Apple’s actions and will fully defend itself,” said Peter Chou, chief executive officer of HTC in the release. “HTC strongly advocates intellectual property protection and will continue to respect other innovators and their technologies as we have always done, but we will continue to embrace competition through our own innovation as a healthy way for consumers to get the best mobile experience possible.”

Chou referred to HTC’s long experience in smartphones, which until recently were largely released under operators’ or other vendors’ brands. In 1999 the company started work on touch screen phones, resulting in the launch of two Microsoft-based touch-enabled phones in 2002 – the XDA and the T-Mobile Pocket PC Phone Edition (left) – five years before the launch of the Apple iPhone.

Since then HTC has built more than 50 smartphone models, said Chou.

The statement promises a strong defence, but will need more detail, as HTC’s 2002 touchscreen phones were stylus driven, and lacked many other elements found in both the iPhone and the Nexus One – as well as other phones based on Google Android operating system.

Apple’s suit is aimed at Google

Click the image to join our Nexus One prize draw

Apple’s suit of HTC is widely seen as a move against Google, to head off a threat from the Nexus One phone, which was hotly awaited before its January launch. The Nexus on was well reviewed, and tipped as a potential threat to the Apple iPhone.

Since then, Nexus One sales have been disappointing and expectations seems to be dampened, although there is still excitement about the phone’s delayed arrival in the UK.

eWEEK Europe already has a SIM-free Nexus One phone, and will offer it to UK subscribers to our newsletter in a prize draw.

While HTC has been hit by a patent suit over the Nexus One technology, Google has been unable to trademark the Nexus One name, as another company already has a telecoms-related trademark for the word Nexus.

Peter Judge

Peter Judge has been involved with tech B2B publishing in the UK for many years, working at Ziff-Davis, ZDNet, IDG and Reed. His main interests are networking security, mobility and cloud

Recent Posts

Microsoft’s Hiring Of Inflection AI Staff Does Not Meet EU Merger Thresholds

European Commission says Microsoft's hiring of Inflection AI's staff will not be investigated under EU…

7 hours ago

Google Urges London Tribunal To Dismiss Mass Lawsuit

Alphabet urges Competition Appeal Tribunal to dismiss mass lawsuit seeking up to £7bn ($9.3bn) for…

8 hours ago

US To Host International Network of AI Safety Institutes In November

The US will host the first meeting of the International Network of AI Safety Institutes,…

9 hours ago

Qualcomm Loses Appeal Over EU Antitrust Fine

EU General Court upholds European Commission €242m antitrust fine against Qualcomm, after it allegedly forced…

11 hours ago

EU Court Rules Google’s €1.49bn Fine Should Be Annulled

Google wins court challenge. Europe's second highest court rules EC's €1.49bn antitrust fine should be…

13 hours ago

Meta Bans Russian State Media Networks

Russian state media networks including RT, Rossiya Segodnya etc banned by Meta Platforms for “foreign…

14 hours ago