MPs Bash BT In BDUK Bust-Up

MPs lambasted BT today over its role in the Broadband Development UK (BDUK) project, which itself took a bashing for delays and process failures.

BT was accused by Margaret Hodge MP of effectively blackmailing the general public by saying it would only go into rural areas where it did not have commercial reasons for doing so only if it received taxpayers’, or government, funding. BDUK, an arm of the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, provides such extra funding from a £530 million pot.

The claims came during a Public Accounts Committee hearing in the House of Commons today, where BT was also told it was a bully, for the way in which it treated others involved in the BDUK initiative.

BT Olympic 1BT ‘a vampire death squid’

Malcolm Corbett, CEO of the Independent Networks Co-operative Association, who was sitting on the panel alongside BT director of strategy Sean Williams, said BT was acting like a “vampire death squid”.

Corbett and others suggested BT was targeting local broadband initiatives by threatening not to bring fibre to rural areas where backing had been voiced for local projects.

BT has already been accused of being a monopolist, as many have pointed to its total dominance of BDUK-associated deals, of which it has won all of them. There are now no other bidders beside BT, so it looks set to sweep up the remaining deals with local councils.

As recently claimed in a scathing report from the National Audit Office, the BDUK project was said to be 22 months behind schedule. But Williams said BT still expects the UK to meet its target of having the best broadband in Europe by 2015.

Overall fibre is supposed to reach 90 percent of the nation via BT infrastructure, with the final 10 percent coming from local initiatives. But BT was also alleged to have witheld details on where that 10 percent is from community bodies.

Williams said it was up to the local councils to decide how they share such information.

Hodge, chair of the committee, described the way BT was acting as an “outrage”. But BT has bitten back, saying it was shocked at the accusations being levelled at it.

“BT is investing billions of pounds to radically improve the UK’s broadband network whilst ensuring all companies have access to it on an equal basis,” a spokesperson said, in an emailed statement sent to TechWeekEurope..

“We are therefore shocked and mystified by some of the ill informed comments played back by members of the committee today. Deploying fibre broadband is a complex long-term investment but that was ignored today as MPs prioritised soundbites over analysis.”

Yet onlookers remain unconvinced by BT’s protestations. “We are glad to see that the NAO report facilitated this much needed scrutiny of the bduk program which is in effect solidifying BT dominance as a monopolistic incumbent,” Dominique Lazanski, of the TaxPayers’ Alliance, told TechWeek.

“Going forward we hope that the entire program is looked at and analysed before further contracts are awarded. We also hope that this hearing will open a reevaluation of the current market regulation.”

Are you fluent in the language of the Internet? Find out with our quiz!

Thomas Brewster

Tom Brewster is TechWeek Europe's Security Correspondent. He has also been named BT Information Security Journalist of the Year in 2012 and 2013.

View Comments

  • Why BT has been allowed to have a virtual monopoly position on the supply of fibre and other telecoms is beyond me. There is only one thing worse then a government monopoly and that is a private one.

    BT should either had to supply the whole country at no cost to the public purse or government take its equivalent share in ownership.

    At the moment for BT its a 'win win' or perhaps it should be 'a rip off, rip off' situation!

Recent Posts

OpenAI Secures $40 Billion Funding Deal With SoftBank, Others

SoftBank has agreed a funding deal that will see OpenAI being provided with up to…

8 hours ago

Tesla Sales Plummet Amid Elon Musk Backlash

Tesla sales have plummeted to lowest level in three years, as deliveries of new EVs…

9 hours ago

Amazon Launches Nova AI Agent To Perform Browser Actions

New addition. Next generation foundation model, as Amazon Nova model launches to perform actions within…

11 hours ago

Meta AI Head Announces Departure

Head of artificial intelligence research at Meta Platforms has announced she is leaving the social…

16 hours ago

CK Hutchison Says No Decision On Telco Spin-off, London Listing

No decision yet, after media reports CK Hutchison was to spin off its global telecom…

16 hours ago