Ministers Object To Default Porn Block

Government ministers are looking to move away from proposals to censor porn by default, after technical and ethical concerns were raised.

Earlier this month, a cross-party Parliamentary inquiry backed up proposals dating back to 2010 to enforce a network-level ‘Opt-In’ system, going beyond the “active choice” model launched by ISPs BT, Sky, TalkTalk and Virgin last October. This would provide a “clean internet feed” as standard, requiring users to specifically request access to “adult” content – an approach which has been criticised as “censorship”.

Yet culture secretary Jeremy Hunt and sources from the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) have indicated such measures would infringe civil liberties, according to reports in the Sun and the Daily Mail.

Instead, Hunt wants ISPs to be forced into providing customers with an “active choice” for filtering porn, which would see end users given the simple task of selecting ‘yes’ or ‘no’ if they wanted access to adult content.

Range of options open

The DCMS offered no specifics, however, in its official line. “It is vital we do all we can to protect children from inappropriate material online,” a DCMS spokesperson said.

“We are looking at a range of options for increasing child protection online and we will be bringing forward proposals later this year.”

A spokesperson from the Internet Services Providers’ Association (ISPA) told TechWeekEurope it stood by its belief that the opt-out model was weak.

“In terms of the pieces in the Sun and Mail, we believe that default filtering of content that customers have to opt out of is ineffective and unnecessary.  Like the Government, we feel that active choice … is a better way forward,” the spokesperson said.

Yet Tory MP Claire Perry has been railing against a lighter touch from government, saying the current opt-in proposals did not go far enough. She wants to see stringent age-checking processes enforced. “Our kids deserve more than empty phrases like civil liberties. If there’s no age check there then we’re not solving the problem,” Perry said.

Are you fluent in the language of the Internet? Try our quiz!

Thomas Brewster

Tom Brewster is TechWeek Europe's Security Correspondent. He has also been named BT Information Security Journalist of the Year in 2012 and 2013.

View Comments

  • If you are looking for full parental control that monitors and controls everything kids do online (such as Facebook), as well as blocks inappropriate websites, and does linguistic analysis to
    watch out for dangerous behavior - such as internet predators or cyberbullying -
    check out McGruff SafeGuard's Parental Control system:
    http://www.GoMcgruff.com

    McGruff “The Crime Dog” - Take A Bite Out of Crime - is well known in the US for family safety.

    For iPad/iPhone parental control, check out http://www.GoMcGruff.com/browser

Recent Posts

Craig Wright Sentenced For Contempt Of Court

Suspended prison sentence for Craig Wright for “flagrant breach” of court order, after his false…

2 days ago

El Salvador To Sell Or Discontinue Bitcoin Wallet, After IMF Deal

Cash-strapped south American country agrees to sell or discontinue its national Bitcoin wallet after signing…

2 days ago

UK’s ICO Labels Google ‘Irresponsible’ For Tracking Change

Google's change will allow advertisers to track customers' digital “fingerprints”, but UK data protection watchdog…

2 days ago

EU Publishes iOS Interoperability Plans

European Commission publishes preliminary instructions to Apple on how to open up iOS to rivals,…

3 days ago

Momeni Convicted In Bob Lee Murder

San Francisco jury finds Nima Momeni guilty of second-degree murder of Cash App founder Bob…

3 days ago