HP has denied claims by the co-CEO of SAP that it tried to sell its ill-starred software acquisition, Autonomy, to the German software giant.
SAP was approached by HP executives offering Autonomy for sale, SAP’s co-CEO Bill McDermott told the Times of London earlier this week. HP denies this, saying that in fact, it was SAP that contacted HP asking to buy software assets – not necessarily including the British information management software vendor. Autonomy has been a thorn in HP’s side since it bought it for $11.3 billion (£7.4bn) in 2011 – and then wrote the asset down by $8.8 billion (£5.8bn), accusing Autonomy executives of fraud.
“Contrary to reports in the media, HP has no interest in selling Autonomy,” read an HP statement,. “During the past year, we’ve received inquiries from SAP about purchasing HP software assets, and time and again, we’ve said ‘no.’ We believe Autonomy will play an important role in HP’s long-term strategy.”
This echoes HP CEO Meg Whitman’s endorsement of the “magical” powers of Autonomy at a press conference in April. McDermott’s claim is that HP was offering Autonomy for sale before her statement – and SAP declined, feeling its own search software HANA was good enough for its needs.
“We were aware that it was on the market at one time but were never seriously interested in Autonomy,” McDermott said.
It’s worth noting that HP is a big SAP customer, with regular meetings between top executives of both companies, and any discussions of this kind might have emerged very informally. It’s not a surprise if the different parties have different recollections of what was said.
SAP has also taken issue with the Times report. Spokesman Jim Dever claimed that HP never “approached” SAP or had talks with it, according to AllThingsD. All McDermott meant was that SAP was “aware that Autonomy was on the market”.
HP bought Autonomy during the short but disastrous tenure of CEO Leo Apotheker, who previously ran SAP. Lawsuits around the purchase continue.
HP is also a customer of OpenText, another Autonomy rival, which is revelling in HP’s discomfort.
Do you remember HP’s glory days? Try our quiz!
Fourth quarter results beat Wall Street expectations, as overall sales rise 6 percent, but EU…
Hate speech non-profit that defeated Elon Musk's lawsuit, warns X's Community Notes is failing to…
Good luck. Russia demands Google pay a fine worth more than the world's total GDP,…
Google Cloud signs up Spotify, Paramount Global as early customers of its first ARM-based cloud…
Facebook parent Meta warns of 'significant acceleration' in expenditures on AI infrastructure as revenue, profits…
Microsoft says Azure cloud revenues up 33 percent for September quarter as capital expenditures surge…
View Comments
CNBC clip: http://video.cnbc.com/gallery/?play=1&video=3000167433
Transcript: >02:30
Kayla: There was a report over the weekend quoting you that said you had been approached about potentially buying it, that you declined, where are those reports coming from, what is the situation from your vantage point?
Bill: First of all, Meg Whitman is a good friend of mine and she and I never had such a conversation about Autonomy. There was a reporter that incorrectly reported the news, basically. And essentially, my comment was, a long time ago before HP ever bought Autonomy, I was aware of the fact that the company was on the market and SAP had passed on the company because we had invented HANA, which is the greatest in-memory database of all time, so there really wasn’t a business rationale by which SAP could move on autonomy. And subsequent to HP buying Autonomy, there has never been a conversation between SAP and HP to do a deal. I don’t know where that comes from other than it’s incorrect, it’s not factual, and I’m here today to set the record straight, Meg and I never had that conservation.
Bill Griffiths, CNBC: It doesn’t get any clearer than that.