The controversial Digital Economy Bill is receiving its second reading in the House of Commons despite requests from MPs from all three major parties to put off the debate until the new Parliament. Turnout for the reading has been very low and even the Conservative shadow minister, who supports it, has described it as “an Amstrad, not an iPod”.
During House of Commons Business, Harriet Harman rejected calls from MPs including Labour’s Tom Watson, the Conservatives’ Roger Gale and David Howarth of the Liberal Democrats for the Bill to be delayed till the next Parliament for a fuller debate. Given the Bill includes things which are “highly controversial,” said David Howarth, “surely she should say that the government will not go through with this.”
“Twenty thousand people have emailed their MPs about this,” pointed out Tom Watson, arguing that the Bill clearly was controversial.
The Bill is having a full second reading debate today, and has already had extensive discussion in the House of Lords – including seven days in committee – said Harriet Harman, leader of the House of Commons.
She also promised some further scrutiny in the next Parliament, “at the point when the regulations are made,” through use of the “super-affirmative procedure” set out in the Parliamentary Reform Act 2001. There will also be “public consultation” over the details of the regulations, by which Ofcom and the courts will monitor interventions by copyright owners against those infringing coyright, when these are finally set out, she said.
I
“I can fully understand the frustration felt by my colleagues,” said Bradshaw, “but there will be damage to the digital economy if there is further delay.” He added: “Hundreds of millions of pounds is hemorrhaging from the digital economy. If we don’t do something about it, it will pose a serous threat to our creative sector.”
Bradshaw attempted to reassure critics that cutting subscribers off would be a last resort after letters had been sent, and most people would amend their behaviour before that happened (which assumes the letters are sent to the actual infringer, of course).
For the Liberal Democrats, Don Foster led an attack on the Bill, while the Tory shadow culture secretary Jeremy Hunt laid into the bill heavily over various flaws, before saying with lost royalties at stake, “the measure is imperfect, but the sensible thing to do is to let it through.”
The UK Pirate Party intends to make this an issue in the General Election announced today.
US widening lead over China on AI development, as UK places third in Stanford index…
Amazon to invest a further $4bn into AI start-up Anthropic, doubling its investment as it…
The demand for tech skills is surging, driving economic growth but revealing challenges. Financial costs,…
US Supreme Court tosses Meta's appeal over Cambridge Analytica-linked investor lawsuit, meaning case must proceed
Uber reportedly seeks $10m stake in Chinese autonomous driving firm Pony AI via US IPO,…
iPhone maker reportedly developing next-generation AI large language model for Siri for spring 2026 as…