Apple has been rebuffed in its efforts to secure an injunction preventing Amazon from using the term ‘Appstore’ to describe its digital downloads storefront.
Apple claims it holds trademark rights over the term – even though its own digital storefront is called the ‘App Store’ (two words). However, a judge in California denied Apple its requested preliminary injunction because it had not established the likelihood of confusion between the two brands.
In an 18-page verdict, Judge Phyliss Hamilton said: “Apple has not established that its “App Store” mark is famous, in the sense of being “prominent” and “renowned”.
eWEEK Europe UK contacted Apple for comment but none was available at the time of writing.
Apple initiated legal action back in March after Amazon launched the Amazon Appstore selling mobile apps to Android users.
The original lawsuit stated: “Amazon has begun improperly using Apple’s App Store mark in connection with Amazon’s mobile software developer program.
“Consumers of mobile software downloads are likely to be confused as to whether Amazon’s mobile software download service is sponsored or approved by Apple.”
This provoked Amazon to launch a countersuit, arguing the case be dismissed on the grounds that ‘App Store’ is a generic term, which Apple denied.
Apple originally bought the trademark ‘App Store’ in the US in 2008, but has since been opposed by Microsoft, with the help of linguists, again on grounds it is a generic term.
Apple’s App Store trademarking has also run into opposition in Europe. In May, Microsoft, Amazon, Sony HTC and Nokia all applied to have Apple’s European trademarks, ‘App Store’ and ‘Appstore’ invalidated.
Tesla vice president of software engineering David Lau reportedly planning to step down amidst political…
Google AI Overview wrongly says Welsh town has won Guinness World Record for roundabouts in…
US president hands TikTok a second 75-day extension for deadline to divest US operations under…
Germany has been paying for OneWeb terminals in Ukraine for past year, says parent company…
Facebook parent Meta abruptly terminates contract with Barcelona-based content moderators amidst policy shift
High Court in Kenya says $2.4bn case against Facebook parent Meta can go ahead, over…
View Comments
They must be kidding! Apple complaining about a tiny change like that?
Don't Apple use iOS? When Cisco have been using IOS for many, many years?
The patent this, copyright that, and sue, counter-sue and sue again attitude needs to stop.