Free Software Campaigner Stallman Attacks Oracle Sun Deal

Chris Preimesberger,

Digital civil liberties organisation Open Rights Group, Knowledge Ecology International and software developer Richard Stallman tell the EC in a letter that they are concerned about Oracle’s possible squashing of competition in the database market by abandoning MySQL

Two software industry groups, along with free and open-source software community leader Richard Stallman, said on 19 Oct they are opposed to Oracle’s planned acquisition of Sun Microsystems and urged European Commission regulators to block the $7.4 billion (£4.5bn) deal.

If the transaction, which was announced on 20 April and approved on 20 Aug. by the U.S. Department of Justice as not being against federal antitrust laws, is sanctioned by the EC, Oracle—through ownership of Sun—will have control of the key maintainers of the popular MySQL database, who work at Sun.

The Open Rights Group, a digital civil liberties organization, Knowledge Ecology International and Stallman told the EC’s Competition Commissioner Neelie Kroes in a co-written letter dated on 19 Oct. that they are concerned about Oracle’s possible squashing of competition in the database market.

“If Oracle is allowed to acquire MySQL, it will predictably limit the development of the functionality and performance of the MySQL software platform, leading to profound harm to those who use MySQL software to power applications,” they wrote.

Stallman, ORG and KEI also said Oracle was likely to protect its core product, the Oracle proprietary database, from losing market share and shrinking licensing fees at the expense of MySQL.

The EC monitors commercial competition in the 27 countries that comprise the European Union. The Brussels-based panel is currently doing due diligence on Oracle’s proposed takeover of Sun and has said it expects to have a decision by Nov. 19 on whether to approve the deal.

Meanwhile, Oracle founder and CEO Larry Ellison has said Sun is losing about $100 million per month as the two companies wait for the EC to make its decision.

Stallman and the other open-source community activists contend that Oracle’s ownership will hinder development of the popular open-source database, which relies heavily on volunteer contributions of time and talent.

MySQL is popular in the data centers of Web 2.0 companies such as Google, Yahoo and Amazon.com and has a loyal following in the midrange and small and midsize business markets.

Oracle makes a number of proprietary transactional databases, and the groups’ contention is that Oracle will allow MySQL to fade away under its management.

Ellison calls Microsoft the main competitor for MySQL

However, Ellison said at the recent Oracle OpenWorld conference in San Francisco, “MySQL in no way competes with our databases. It has its own market and following. The main competitor is Microsoft, and that’s okay by us.”

There is a difference of opinion on this, even among MySQL founders. On 19 Oct, MySQL creator Michael Widenius urged Oracle to commit to selling MySQL in order to resolve antitrust concerns.

Back on 8 Oct, former MySQL CEO Mårten Mickos sent a letter to Kroes, urging that the deal be approved for the good of the market and MySQL.

Kroes told Reuters in September that she was concerned that the acquisition could hinder competition in the database market and wanted to make sure alternatives would continue to be available to users.