Samsung Loses Again, Ordered To Pay Apple In Patent Retrial

The protracted and bitter patent lawsuit between Apple and Samsung has taken a fresh twist after nearly seven years of legal battle between the two tech giants.

A US jury took five days to reach a decision on Thursday that Samsung should pay $539m to Apple for copying patented smartphone features.

The decision could mark the final stages of a bitter lawsuit that began in a US courtroom way back in 2011.

Jury decision

In August 2012, a federal jury in San Jose, California, awarded Apple $1.05 billion (£661m) in damages, after a three-week trial and three days of deliberations. The jury ruled that Samsung’s infringement on Apple products was “willful.”

Offending products included the Samsung Galaxy Tab and Galaxy 10.1 tablets and Samsung’s line of Galaxy S smartphones.

Ever since then the two firms have been fighting over the final damages settlement. In May 2015 a US appeals court reduced the amount to $548m.

Samsung has previously labelled Apple‘s patent infringement case against it as nothing more than an attack on Google’s Android operating system, and an attempt to stifle competition in the smartphone market.

Apple had at some stages been seeking more $2bn for patent violations for Samsung allegedly infringing aspects of iPhone design.

Samsung has also paid Apple $399m to compensate Apple for infringement of some of the patents at issue in the case. If this latest award is upheld on appeal, Samsung will have to pay Apple an additional $140m.

The current retrial in San Jose, California, before Judge Lucy Koh had centred on the amount Samsung had to pay Apple. Arguments in the case ended on 18 May, and the jury has been deliberating the case since last week.

Apple had been seeking $1 billion of the profits Samsung made from selling infringing phones. It alleged that the iPhone’s design was crucial to their success.

Samsung had sought to limit damages to about $28 million.

Compromise amount?

In a statement, Apple was reported by Reuters as saying that it was pleased that the members of the jury “agree that Samsung should pay for copying our products.”

“We believe deeply in the value of design,” Apple said in its statement. “This case has always been about more than money.”

Samsung did not immediately say whether it planned to appeal the verdict but said it was retaining “all options” to contest it.

“Today’s decision flies in the face of a unanimous Supreme Court ruling in favour of Samsung on the scope of design patent damages,” Samsung said in a statement. “We will consider all options to obtain an outcome that does not hinder creativity and fair competition for all companies and consumers.”

Quiz: How well do you know Apple?

Tom Jowitt

Tom Jowitt is a leading British tech freelancer and long standing contributor to Silicon UK. He is also a bit of a Lord of the Rings nut...

Recent Posts

Apple, Google Mobile Ecosystems Should Be Investigated, CMA Told

CMA receives 'provisional recommendation' from independent inquiry that Apple,Google mobile ecosystem needs investigation

2 days ago

Australia Rejects Elon Musk Claim About Social Media Ban For Under-16s

Government minister flatly rejects Elon Musk's “unsurprising” allegation that Australian government seeks control of Internet…

2 days ago

Northvolt Files For Bankruptcy Protection In US

Northvolt files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the United States, and CEO and co-founder…

2 days ago

UK’s CMA Readies Cloud Sector “Behavioural” Remedies – Report

Targetting AWS, Microsoft? British competition regulator soon to announce “behavioural” remedies for cloud sector

3 days ago

Former Policy Boss At X, Nick Pickles, Joins Sam Altman Venture

Move to Elon Musk rival. Former senior executive at X joins Sam Altman's venture formerly…

3 days ago

Bitcoin Rises Above $96,000 Amid Trump Optimism

Bitcoin price rises towards $100,000, amid investor optimism of friendlier US regulatory landscape under Donald…

3 days ago