Mixed results for both Twitter and Elon Musk, after the latest ruling by a US judge in the lead up to a courtroom showdown.

A judge rejected Elon Musk’s demands for Twitter user details as “absurdly broad” on Thursday, Reuters reported. That said, Twitter has been ordered to hand some data over to Musk concerning thousands of users.

The judge ordered Twitter to turn over data from 9,000 active users accounts that were sampled in a fourth-quarter (2021) audit. That data was used by Twitter to estimate the number of spam or bot users on the social media platform.

Tesla and SpaceX chief executive Elon Musk. Image credit: SpaceX

Legal battle

The number of spam or bot users on the social media platform is at the heart of the reason for Elon Musk terminating his agreed $44 billion deal to acquire the social media platform.

Twitter is suing Elon Musk over his withdrawal from the deal, and Musk in turn is counter suing Twitter.

Both are due to appear in court on 17 October for a five day trial.

Earlier this week Elon Musk subpoenaed former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey, who has previously supported Musk’s takeover attempt, and has also criticised Twitter’s board of directors, despite vocal concerns from staff and users about Musk’s acquisition.

Twitter had in April this year said that less than 5 percent of Twitter users are spam or fake accounts.

Musk however believes the true figure of fake or bot accounts is closer to 20 percent or more.

Judge’s ruling

On Thursday Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick of Delaware’s Court of Chancery said many of Musk’s data demands were “absurdly broad,” amounting to trillions of data points that “no one in their right mind has ever tried to undertake such an effort.”

The judge also said Musk has had data and documents needed to pursue his case, much of which was provided before he said on 8 July he was terminating the deal in part because Twitter was withholding information.

“My overall impression is that plaintiff has agreed to produce a tremendous amount of information to defendants, and that the information plaintiff has agreed to produce is sufficiently broad to satisfy most of plaintiff’s obligations,” wrote Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick of Delaware’s Court of Chancery.

Twitter was ordered to turn over data from 9,000 accounts sampled in a fourth-quarter audit to estimate the number of spam or bot users on the social media platform.

Twitter had said that data no longer existed and it would be burdensome to recreate it, although McCormick gave the company two weeks to produce it.

Audit data

“We look forward to reviewing the data Twitter has been hiding for many months,” said Musk’s attorney, Alex Spiro, told Reuters in an emailed statement.

Twitter declined to comment.

Musk has said he wants to test that audit’s accuracy because he believes the company fraudulently misrepresented that only 5 percent of its accounts were spam. He wants McCormick to rule he can walk away from the deal.

Twitter said at a Wednesday court hearing that Musk’s focus on spam was “legally irrelevant” because the company has described the spam count in regulatory filings as an estimate, not a representation.

It also said the real level of spam could be higher.

Tom Jowitt

Tom Jowitt is a leading British tech freelancer and long standing contributor to Silicon UK. He is also a bit of a Lord of the Rings nut...

Recent Posts

Spyware Maker NSO Group Found Liable In US Court

Landmark ruling finds NSO Group liable on hacking charges in US federal court, after Pegasus…

1 day ago

Microsoft Diversifying 365 Copilot Away From OpenAI

Microsoft reportedly adding internal and third-party AI models to enterprise 365 Copilot offering as it…

1 day ago

Albania Bans TikTok For One Year After Stabbing

Albania to ban access to TikTok for one year after schoolboy stabbed to death, as…

1 day ago

Foldable Shipments Slow In China Amidst Global Growth Pains

Shipments of foldable smartphones show dramatic slowdown in world's biggest smartphone market amidst broader growth…

1 day ago

Google Proposes Remedies After Antitrust Defeat

Google proposes modest remedies to restore search competition, while decrying government overreach and planning appeal

1 day ago

Sega Considers Starting Own Game Subscription Service

Sega 'evaluating' starting its own game subscription service, as on-demand business model makes headway in…

1 day ago